Let's Go! - LFG Playoffs recap for May 11, 2025

Shawn Michaels meets with the Legends and the remaining Future Greats. He announces that this week, the remaining eight Future Greats will be whittled down to four. It it apparently from the Future Greats that the mood has shifted.

The Legends talk among themselves before the future Great Legends has promo battles. Chris Island and Shiloh Hill start. Shiloh Hill mentions Chris Island's hometown while Island brings up Shiloh getting injured. It gets to the point that both men have to be separated by the referee. Afterwards, both men realize how real this is. Penina Tuilalepa and Zena Sterling go next, and Zena takes the stoic route and walks out on Penina as while Penina gets in her face. This leads to Bubba Ray and Penina having words with each other, with Bubba Ray telling Penina that Zena destroyed her in that promo battle. BJ Ray and Jasper Troy are next, and BJ says he does not see much of a beast in Jasper while Jasper tells BJ that he is not taken seriously and that he "the two minute segment before the commercial break." BJ chalks it up to Jasper being "a fat ugly bitch" who is jealous of him, and says that Booker "dick rides" Jasper Troy. Dani and Tyra Mae are the last two, and Tyra Mae gets right in Dani's face while Dani tells Tyra Mae she is not the nobody that she thinks she is.

Dani Sekelsky beats Tyra Mae Steele by submission with the Hell's Gate. The Undertaker and Mickie James are both proud of them, with Mickie saying that this match is a "night and day" difference from the first one that they had.

Jasper Troy beats BJ Ray. Booker T and Bubba Ray Dudley both feel that BJ is not taking his time in the ring like he should.

Penina Tiulalepa beats Zena Sterling. Booker T and Bubba Ray agree that both of them did well, and Penina says she would not have made it through that match without Zena.

Shiloh Hill beats Chris Island. The Undertaker says that both of them told a great story, and Mickie James says that there was some fire and chemistry to the match.

The points are awarded. For the women, Booker T says that Tyra Mae and Dani still have a lot to work on, then says that Zena is the woman he is not proud of. The Undertaker votes Tyra, but admits that all of the women have done well. Mickie James gives her point to Dani. Bubba Ray says Tyra Mae and Dani did well, but had a problem figuring out what their match was. Afer asking Penina who she feels deserves the point between her and Zena and Penina says she deserves the point (with the reason that she will back herself every single time), he goes with Zena. As for the men, Booker T gives his point to Jasper for being the most complete competitor out of the four. The Undertaker votes for Shiloh, with Chris Island being his second choice and Jasper being third, and that starts an argument between Booker and Undertaker . Mickie James gives her vote to Chris after Bubba Ray gets mad at Jasper for saying he can only do so much with what he was given and take this as burying BJ, then Bubba Ray stands up out of his chair. He says that he knows that Jasper wants this so badly, but knows that Jasper had to work with someone who did not complement him. He tells Chris Island has had issues in the past but is doing well, and that he should continue to do well. He says Shiloh has impressed him since day one, and tells Shiloh that he has gotten his vote.

The eliminations take place. Between Tyra Mae and Dani, Dani is eliminated, with Mickie being the lone vote against Tyra Mae. Between BJ and Jasper, BJ is eliminated unanimously. BJ thanks Mickie and The Undertaker, tells Booker T that he is blinded by personal bias, then tells Bully Ray that he will end him if he ever touches him again. Between Penina and Zena, Penina is eliminated unanimously, but everyone admits that Penina has plenty of potential. Between Chris Island and Shiloh Hill, Chris Island is eliminated unanimously, with Mickie James saying that she and Chris Island are going home together. Zena, Tyra Mae, Jasper and Shiloh continue on to Madison Square Garden for the finals.