Honor Roll - Ring of Honor recap for May 4, 2019

Rhett Titus guests on commentary for the next match.

"The Darewolf" PJ Black beats Eli Isom.

Before the next match, Ray Lyn tells Kelly Klein that she does not like or respect her, and that she will not shake her hand.

Kelly Klein beats Ray Lyn. After the match, Klein tells Ray Lyn she will respect her, and both women shake hands. She also says that she would be a fighting champion and represent what the Women of Honor World Championship stands for when she gets in the ring. She calls her recent title win the greatest moment of her career, then somebody wanted to take it from her to get attention, saying that somebody cares about social media and looks while she cares about wrestling, which is what Women of Honor is all about. Suddenly, Velvet Sky and "The Exotic Goddess" Mandy Leon show up on the stage, and Angelina Love sneaks up on Kenny Klein to lay her out with a running kick. Jenny Rose runs in, but she is easily overpowered, and Velvet Sky takes a marker to Jenny's forehead.

Dalton Castle shows up. He says that he owes a lot of people an explanation, and two people more than anything. He asks for The Boys to come to the ring, and The Boys show up. Castle asks them to enter the ring as he just wants to make things right, and that what happened at G1 Supercard. When he moves towards The Boys, The Boys move away, and Castle tells them that he was frustrated following his loss to Rush and that he should never have taken his frustration out on them. He tells them that he does not want to throw their friendship away over a mistake, and asks that they move past this and shoot forward like they always have. The Boys accept Castle's apology, and Castle tells the fans that what they are looking at is stronger than ever and that the fans will not see him put his hands on The Boys again, for they are no boys of his. He then attacks The Boys again before taking their masks.

LifeBlood (Mark Haskins and "Hot Sauce" Tracy Williams) beat The Kingdom (Vinny Marseglia and TK O'Ryan) with the Sharpshooter to TK O'Ryan. After the match, Williams declares that Bully Ray has been nothing but a cancer in ROH and that cutting him out completely is the only way to get rid of him. Williams calls out Bully Ray, and Bully Ray eventually shows up and tells them to go to Hell.