Honor Roll - Ring of Honor recap for November 3, 2018

Before the next match, Bully Ray - who shows up with a manila envelope with "Flip Punishment" on it - mentions that if "The Last Real Man" Silas Young wins, then he can do whatever he wants to do to Flip Gordon; likewise, if Flip wins, he can do whatever he can do to Bully Ray. When Flip shows up (with a manila envelope saying "Bully Ray Punishment"), he points to the commentary table, revealing that his mystery partner is Colt Cabana. Bully Ray is not impressed with Flip's choice - having beaten Colt Cabana in Las Vegas, Nevada - but Colt Cabana says he is here to see what Bully Ray's face would look like when he finds out it is not him, but instead, it is The Sandman, who shows up out of the crowd with a can of beer and a Singapore cane.

"The Last Real Man" Silas Young beats The Sandman in a Pick Your Punishment Match. After the match, Bully Ray announces that Flip Gordon will take ten shots from The Sandman's Singapore cane. (The ten lashes are edited and censored for international TV, with the full, uncut footage appearing on Honor Club.) During the beating, Bully Ray gives Flip the opportunity to say "I quit," which Flip rejects. As Flip takes the lashes, more and more people from the locker room show up to watch and confront Bully Ray, and "The American Nightmare" Cody Rhodes shows up with The Young Bucks (Matt and Nick Jackson) and gets in the ring to tell Flip to take it, as does everyone else who has showed up to watch. Bully Ray gives Flip another chance to quit, and Flip replies with "Fuck you!" The tenth Singapore cane shot ends up being a low blow, and Bully Ray has to defend himself on his way to the back.

"The Exotic Goddess" Mandy Leon guests on commentary for the next match.

Jenny Rose, Madison Rayne and Sumie Sakai beat Karen Q, Britt Baker and Kelly Klein after Kelly Klein refuses to be a team player.

We hear from The Kingdom (Matt Taven, Vinny Marseglia, TK O'Ryan). Vinny Marseglia asks Jay Lethal if the underside of the ring looks familiar, and Taven says the red balloons were the last thing Lethal says before he popped his bubble showed him who the real World champion is. TK O'Ryan says Lethal and Johnathan Gresham's mystery does not scare them, and tells Lethal to "go ahead and call Will Ospreay." Marseglia then says to check under the ring, whoever you are.

Jay Lethal guests on commentary for the next match.

"The American Nightmare" Cody Rhodes beats Kenny King by disqualification. During the match, Kenny King throws an elbow pad at Brandi Rhodes, and Cody Rhodes grabs the IWGP United States Championship to use as a weapon. Senior referee Todd Sinclair is brought in as an enforcer. After that, King kicks Cody in the groin, then Jay Lethal runs out from the commentary table and tries to talk sense into Kenny King. Kenny King responds by hitting Kenny King with the IWGP United States title from behind.